OPERATOR'S GUIDE
In-House Security VS Outsourcing Security Guard Services: What Actually Works
You have a property that needs security. Now you have a decision to make. Do you hire your own team and run everything yourself, or do you hire a security company and let them handle staffing, training, supervision, and liability?
START SECURITY SERVICES TODAY
For most properties, outsourcing is faster and more flexible. But that doesn't mean it's always the right call.
It depends on your budget, your risk level, how hands-on you want to be day to day, and whether you have the time to recruit, train, and supervise guards yourself.
Define Your Options Before You Compare Them
Before you weigh cost or supervision, get clear on what each model actually means in practice — staffing, licensing, who carries liability, and where the day-to-day work lives.
What Is In-House (Proprietary) Security?
If you hire a guard directly instead of going through a security company, that guard needs a valid proprietary guard card. It's different from the regular guard card most contract officers carry, which is regulated by the California Bureau of Security and Investigative Services.
Once you bring that guard on, they go on your payroll. You handle background checks, track guard card renewals, train them, schedule them, and supervise them.
Some larger organizations prefer this because they want full control. Banks, hospitals, and corporate campuses sometimes go this route because they need officers who only answer to internal management.
It's a lot to take on. You're now responsible for recruiting, payroll, workers' comp, liability coverage, and making sure every officer meets state training requirements.
The biggest issue we see with in-house teams is supervision. Without an outside system keeping officers honest, missed checkpoints and skipped patrols go unnoticed. Nobody is watching the watchers. Silvertrac logs from properties that switched to contract security consistently show patrol gaps that went on for months before anyone caught them.
What Is Contract Security?
Contract security means you hire a licensed security company to provide guards, handle scheduling, run training, and take on the liability. You pay an hourly rate. The company sends the guards, runs the supervision, owns the reporting system, and covers shifts when someone calls out.
The contract between your property and the provider should spell out post orders, shift schedules, checkpoint requirements, reporting standards, and what happens when something goes wrong. If those specifics aren't in there, you're signing a staffing agreement, not a security agreement.
This model works well for property managers, HOA boards, event planners, facility managers, and business owners who need reliable coverage without standing up their own security department. Your security gets handled by people who do this work full time.
Where Both Models Break Down
How In-House Security Fails
In-house security runs into trouble when the person managing the team has another full-time job. Property managers are busy. Facility directors have other priorities pulling at them.
When nobody is actively supervising the guards, things slip. Officers start treating every area the same. They might skip a patrol location, miss a QR code scan, or sit in the lobby instead of walking the property. There's no system flagging what got missed.
How Outsourced Security Fails
Outsourced security breaks down when you hire a company that treats the contract like a staffing job instead of a security operation. They send an untrained guard. That guard shows up, sits at the front desk, and does the bare minimum. No site assessment before the first shift. No custom post orders. No checkpoint verification. No supervisor checking in at 2 a.m.
Silvertrac data from properties we've taken over shows most missed checkpoints happen between 2 and 5 a.m. on overnight shifts. That's when fatigue sets in and supervision matters most. If your current provider can't tell you what their officers did at 2:15 a.m. last Tuesday, that's a red flag.
Benefits of Outsourcing Your Security Operations
Hardest Parts Off Your Plate
When you outsource, the hardest parts of running security come off your plate. You don't have to recruit officers, run background checks, track guard card renewals, manage payroll, or carry workers' comp and general liability insurance for a security team. The contract company takes care of all of it.
Scale Up or Down With a Phone Call
When you need to add a shift for a special event, scale up to 24/7 during a construction phase, or cut back to weekends only, the company adjusts. No hiring. No layoffs. Just a phone call.
Supervision That Actually Verifies
The part that matters most though is supervision. A good contract security company runs a system most in-house teams can't match. At Safeguard, every shift runs under three layers: GPS-verified Silvertrac reporting, live 24/7 dispatch monitoring, and unannounced field supervisor checks. Building that kind of oversight in-house would cost tens of thousands of dollars a year.
Turnover Becomes Their Problem
Turnover is another thing nobody likes to talk about. Industry-wide, security officer turnover runs above 100% a year. A contract company handles finding and replacing officers so you don't start over every time someone leaves.
need help deciding what to choose?
Not sure what the better option is for your business? Contact us today, and we can help you decide.
In-House vs. Contract Security: Side by Side
Supervision is the biggest gap between the two models. Most in-house teams don't have a dedicated security manager watching checkpoints. They rely on trust. A contract company with a real supervision system doesn't rely on trust alone. It verifies the work and logs the proof.
Hiring costs and liability are the other two differences that hit your budget directly. Building an in-house team means paying for recruiting, background checks, BSIS licensing, uniforms, equipment, training, and ongoing payroll. When you employ officers directly, your business carries the liability too. Workers' comp claims, lawsuits from incidents on site, and insurance premiums all land on your books. With a contract company, those costs are built into the hourly rate, and the provider carries their own liability coverage.
Then there's backup staffing. When your in-house officer calls out at midnight, you're scrambling to fill the post. A security vendor with a reserve roster can fill an open shift within hours. At Safeguard, our dispatch team handles guard replacement and can usually cover an open shift in two to four hours through our shift coverage process.
| Factor | In-House (Proprietary) | Contract Security |
|---|---|---|
| Supervision | ✕Relies on trust; no dedicated security manager watching checkpoints | ✓Verifies the work and logs the proof |
| Hiring Costs | ✕Recruiting, background checks, BSIS licensing, uniforms, equipment, training, ongoing payroll | ✓Built into the hourly rate |
| Liability | ✕Your business carries it — workers' comp claims, lawsuits from incidents, insurance premiums | ✓Provider carries their own liability coverage |
| Backup Staffing | ✕Officer calls out at midnight, you're scrambling to fill the post | ✓Reserve roster fills open shift within hours — Safeguard typically covers in 2 to 4 hours |
| Daily Management | ✕You're recruiting, training, supervising, and running payroll | ✓Provider does the work full time |
"Professional team that takes security seriously. Response times excellent, communication top notch."
"Best security company in the area. They go above and beyond what's expected. Highly recommend."
"Outstanding service. Guards well-trained, attentive, truly care about the properties they protect."
"Excellent service from day one. Our property is secure and we have complete peace of mind."
"Safeguard Security has amazing service. Guards are polite, productive, efficient and trustworthy."
"Great service and great pricing. Very professional! Glad we chose to partner with SafeGuard."
Why Safeguard Is Different from Other Security Vendors
Our three-layer supervision system isn't a marketing line. It runs on every shift at every site. GPS-verified Silvertrac reporting, live dispatch monitoring, and random field supervisor visits. You don't have to wonder whether the guard is actually patrolling. You can see it in the data.
Silvertrac GPS Reporting
Every patrol checkpoint logged with GPS coordinates and timestamps. Clients access reports directly.
Verified Data24/7 Live Dispatch
Late or missing reports flagged within 15 minutes. Dispatch contacts officers when check-ins are late.
Real-Time WatchUnannounced Field Visits
Field supervisors make random site visits. No advance notice. Confirms post-order compliance.
Surprise AuditsOne question we hear a lot is: how do I know the guard is doing the job? Here's how. Our dispatch team monitors every checkpoint. If a 2:00 a.m. report isn't submitted by 2:15, dispatch calls the officer directly. Silvertrac logs the GPS timestamp and officer ID. If the officer can't account for the gap, the supervisor gets notified right away.
Most companies send a salesperson to walk the lobby and call it a site assessment. We send a field supervisor who has worked security operations for years. They look at every access point, every blind spot, and every area where incidents actually happen. The post orders we build come from that walkthrough, not a template.
Shift handoff is another area where we're different. Every officer completes a written handoff that covers incidents, ongoing situations, and anything the next officer needs to know. This isn't a quick chat in the parking lot. It's logged in Silvertrac.
What Affects Pricing: Contract Security vs. In-House
The average hourly rate for contract security runs $27 to $35 for unarmed officers and $35 to $55 for armed officers. Where your property lands in that range depends on a few things.
Contract Security · Hourly Rate Range
In-house security usually costs 10% to 20% more once you add up recruiting, training, benefits, workers' comp insurance, liability coverage, uniforms, equipment, and management time. Contract security puts all of that into one hourly rate with no surprises.
What Drives Where You Land in That Range
Property Complexity
The biggest factor is how complex your property is. A single-entrance office building costs less to cover than a residential community with six access points, a pool area, a clubhouse, and a parking structure. More ground to cover means more patrol time, more checkpoints, and sometimes more guards.
Coverage Hours
Coverage hours matter too. Overnight shifts and holidays cost more than weekday daytime hours.
Risk Level
Risk plays a role as well. A property with constant incidents, one that handles high-value inventory, or a location near a high-crime area may need more experienced officers or armed coverage. Both raise the rate.
You might think you're saving money by paying the guard $22 an hour instead of paying a security company $29 an hour. Once everything else is on the table, you usually end up paying the same or more.
Why Clients Trust Safeguard
Safeguard Security Services operates under PPO License #122311, issued by the California Bureau of Security and Investigative Services (BSIS). We're licensed and insured with over 20 years of experience providing security across commercial, residential, industrial, and event properties in Southern California.
Every officer is BSIS-licensed, background checked, and trained in de-escalation, customer service, and report writing. Our supervision runs on Silvertrac digital reporting, real-time dispatch monitoring, and unannounced field supervisor visits.
Areas We Serve
We cover commercial, residential, industrial, and event properties all across Southern California. Wherever your property is, you get the same service — patrols tracked in Silvertrac, dispatch watching every shift, and field supervisors showing up without warning. Below is where our teams spend most of their time.
San Fernando Valley
Westside & Beach Cities
LA Metro & Foothills
Conejo Valley
Not Sure Which Model Is Right for Your Property?
If you’re weighing in-house security against outsourcing, we can help you figure out which option makes sense for your property, your budget, and your risk level. We’ll walk your site, look at your current setup, and give you an honest recommendation.
Contact us today to schedule a free site assessment. The conversation starts with your property, not a sales pitch.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is contract security?
Contract security is when a business hires a licensed security company to provide guards, supervision, and reporting instead of employing officers directly. The security company handles staffing, training, liability, and keeping officers in check. You pay an hourly rate and get fully managed coverage.
How do security contracts work?
You sign an agreement with a security provider that lets them deliver guard services to your property or event. The contract should cover hours of coverage, post orders, checkpoint requirements, reporting standards, and what happens when something goes wrong.
The provider supplies licensed officers, manages their schedules, supervises their performance, and sends replacements when someone calls out or leaves. A good contract also spells out supervision standards and step-by-step procedures for handling incidents.
How much do companies pay for security guards?
Unarmed contract security usually runs $27 to $35 an hour. Armed officers run $35 to $55 an hour. The rate depends on how complex the property is, how many hours you need, the risk level, and whether specialized training is required.
What is a proprietary private security officer?
A proprietary private security officer is a guard hired directly by a business or property owner. They're on your payroll, and you're responsible for their licensing, training, supervision, workers' comp, and liability coverage. You get full control, but you're taking on a lot of management work.
Is outsourcing security guard services worth it?
For most properties, yes. Outsourcing takes the work of recruiting, training, scheduling, and supervising officers off your plate. It also moves the liability over to the security provider and gives you backup staffing, digital reporting, and built-in supervision that would be expensive to build yourself.
The key is picking a company that actually watches its officers, not one that just sends a body. Why clients choose Safeguard.
How does Safeguard supervise its security guards?
We use a three-layer system. Layer one is Silvertrac digital reporting with GPS-verified checkpoints and timestamps. Layer two is live 24/7 dispatch monitoring that flags late or missing reports within 15 minutes. Layer three is unannounced field supervisor visits at all active posts. You can pull reports any time you want.
What happens if a guard calls out or doesn't show up?
We keep a team of reserve officers on standby for exactly this. No-shows are rare, but when one happens, our dispatch team sends a replacement and can usually fill the shift in two to four hours. Your site doesn't go uncovered.
What training do Safeguard officers receive?
Every officer is licensed through BSIS and trained in de-escalation, report writing, customer service, and emergency response — see our full training and certifications page. Before their first shift at your site, they're briefed on your specific post orders, patrol routes, checkpoint locations, and what to do if something goes wrong. Training isn't a one-time event. Officers get ongoing refreshers and performance reviews.
Why should I choose a contract security company over hiring the cheapest option?
A lower hourly rate usually means the company pays its officers less. That leads to higher turnover, less experienced guards, and weaker supervision. You end up cycling through new faces every few weeks with no consistency.
The right question isn't who's cheapest. It's who actually supervises their guards and can prove it.
What happens when a property has no real security supervision?
Without someone watching, officers start cutting corners. They skip checkpoints, stick to the easy routes, and stop paying attention. Silvertrac data from properties we've taken over shows most missed checkpoints happen between 2 and 3 a.m.
You end up paying for a guard, but you're not getting the patrol activity you're paying for. That's a false sense of coverage.